It is up around 21% since March - same as the index, so it hasn't outperformed. since around October, it has been down 5% - vs a 16% rise in the index. It is down around 16% since its January highs - vs the index which is up around 1% since Jan. All in all, I would say the analyst community has been spot on, wouldn't you?
No, it was R135 in March 2012, then ran to over R200. That is hardly a good SELL call (up 50%+)? I can understand the sell call when it overshot at R200. Its only of late that it pulled back. All I'm really trying to say is that even those in the "know" also don't always know